Oh My! Peanut Butter Pie

Oh. My.

One day, pretty far into what I would consider my ‘adult life’, I realized, “Whatever happened to the Peanut Butter Pie?!” I grew up in the South where this is a common place dessert, but I had later moved up North where seemingly it was nowhere to be found so thus I had completely forgotten about it. I needed to address this serious issue promptly. First, this might be my very favorite pie. Ever. It’s cool, it’s creamy, and there’s no baking which is a prerequisite for good summertime desserts, am I right?! Oh, and it’s ridiculously easy to make, I promise, no sweating.

Oh My!  Peanutbutter Pie by Meredith MyersBird’s Peanut Butter Pie

Ok so I cheated a little and I do use a premade pie crust… 

1 store bought pie crust of the cookie or graham cracker variety (I LOVE oreo)

1 – 8oz block of cream cheese, softened

1 cup of sugar

1 tsp vanilla

1 cup creamy peanut butter

1 Tb softened butter

1 cup heavy cream

Beat together cream cheese, butter, peanut butter, sugar, and vanilla until smooth.

Whip the heavy cream until thick and creamy and fold delicately into the peanut butter mixture.

Spread this mixture into prepare pie crust.

Refrigerate for several hours for light and fluffy or Freeze for a couple hours for thick & creamy.

Meredith Myers
Meredith is a devoted mom to 2 beautiful beings: an angel girl and boy, both on the autism spectrum. She is also a wife to her wise soul and friend, an artist, a musician, a gamer, a foodie, a spiritual light bearer, and a positive experience facilitator. Meredith (aka Bird) says her children are her true inspiration and ultimate life lesson. She trusts in God to guide her daily in all her endeavors. She is known as Bird and there is not another like her!
Meredith Myers

Latest posts by Meredith Myers (see all)

 

Meredith Myers
Meredith is a devoted mom to 2 beautiful beings: an angel girl and boy, both on the autism spectrum. She is also a wife to her wise soul and friend, an artist, a musician, a gamer, a foodie, a spiritual light bearer, and a positive experience facilitator. Meredith (aka Bird) says her children are her true inspiration and ultimate life lesson. She trusts in God to guide her daily in all her endeavors. She is known as Bird and there is not another like her!
Meredith Myers

Latest posts by Meredith Myers (see all)

46 Responses to Oh My! Peanut Butter Pie

  1. Nena Sinclair says:

    OMG!! This looks so good that I wanted to print the picture and eat it!! Lol this is one for the “Gotta Make ASAP” file!! Thanks for the recipe!!

  2. Karina Lee says:

    yum!!

  3. Stephanie Larison says:

    Wow, this looks amazing!

  4. Marie Shackelford says:

    My son will love this…Thanks

  5. Kimberly R. says:

    always love new recipes, thanks.

  6. Michelle Proper says:

    Thanks! Will make this..I’m a peanut butter fanatic!!!

  7. Mihai Ioan Bizga says:

    Delicious!!!

  8. Renee Travis says:

    I have a recipe that is similar and everyone loves it. I was born and raised in Missouri and we just love it. We top ours with mini chocolate chips! Yours looks wonderful!!! :)

  9. Pam says:

    This seems easy enough and looks terrific! Will try it soon.

  10. Jennifer Kreisler says:

    My mother makes this it is yum!

  11. Alana Vester says:

    This looks yummy! I love peanut butter anything! :-)

  12. Starlia C. says:

    This looks really good! I can’t wait to try it and get the kids reactions. Thank you for psoting.

  13. Lesli Robertson says:

    YUMMY cant wait to try this pie, thanks for sharing.

  14. Kathy Idol says:

    This is so yummy looking. Needed another pie for Christmas party. Thanks for sharing

  15. Stephanie Hastie says:

    Love peanut butter!

  16. ANN*H says:

    We love peanut butter pie, tho I never made one of them myself. This recipe sounds so easy to make, I think I will try making it tomorrow for Christmas. Great dessert for our holiday parties. Thanks so much for the recipe.

  17. Patricia Mohl says:

    I’ll have TO MAKE THIS FOR MY DAD

  18. Dana says:

    Wow! Being from Chicago, I’ve never heard of this. It’s going on the list for Christmas desert tomorrow! Thanks.

  19. Julie Wood says:

    This is such a delicious recipe for this pie! I like the recipe and am going to make it. I pinned this recipe to my Pinterest account. Thanks for posting an awesome pie recipe!

  20. crissi mcveay says:

    looks perfect, bet it was yummy too!

  21. lisa lo says:

    Pinned

    http://pinterest.com/pin/101894010291038912/

    I love EZ recipes as I have a bad back and cannot stand a long time to cook in the kitchen like I did way back when.

  22. Alison says:

    want to try it!

  23. Niki Mattes says:

    OMGosh peanut butter heaven :) yum!

  24. Pamela Halligan says:

    My family LOVES peanut butter, so I’ll definitely be trying your Peanut Butter Pie recipe. Thanks for sharing. It sounds so delicious.

  25. Rhea Stogsdill Chladek says:

    This looks scrumptious, but dangerous. (I would probably be the only person in my household who would eat it!)

    :) Rhea

  26. Maria Delgado says:

    Oh my! I NEED this.

  27. Bird says:

    Wow thank you everyone for your kind comments! this is truly to die for haha Blessings to all <3

  28. Gloria Walshver says:

    It looks delicious.

  29. Chrystal D says:

    That looks SO good! Thanks for the recipe!

  30. I’ve eaten other people’s p’nut butter pies, but never made one myself but I believe I will make this recipe. It seems to be very simple & delicious!

  31. Bird says:

    Thank you sweet ladies, hope you are all able to enjoy it soon :)

  32. Betsy Barnes says:

    I just made this for Christmas and added chopped Peanut Butter Cups in the mixture and put some on top as decorations. It was amazing :)

  33. June says:

    Looks so good, maybe just a sliver!

  34. katherine minor says:

    Delicious!!

  35. misty farmer says:

    My kidos would love this!! Thanks!

  36. THIS REALLY LOOKS AND SOUNDS GOOD–HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!!!!!!!!!!

  37. Huguette English says:

    Oh yum! Seems easy enough to make too! Thanks for sharing added to my recipe pins to try :)

  38. Debbie says:

    OH YUMMY! I have never even heard of peanut butter pie! I have got to make this. Thank you so much for sharing your recipe.

Leave a Reply